Saucer – Why Hoppin’ John on New Years Day? - Blue-eyed eaterHoppin’ John a dish made of a combination of beans, rice, greens and/or pork, depending on whom you consult. Eating the dish at the start of the calendar year is supposed to bring good luck and good fortune in the subsequent 12 months.
Beans are said to represent coins and the greens represent dollars (the optional corn bread = gold). Apparently the belief you are what you eat, even allegorically, inspired this custom. Historically, a dime was buried in the dish and whoever unearthed it was supposed receive extra goodwill and fortune during the year. Avoiding symbolism, some believe that black-eyed peas are good fortune because during the waning days of the Civil War the Union Army ignored the beans in the field, either uninterested in them as food or mistaking them for fodder, leaving fortunate southerners with something to eat as the calendar changed to 1866.
Except that bit of folklore would require the belief that all the Union forces led by different commanders in Virginia, the Carolinas, Georgia and Louisiana left one particular crop untouched for the same reason. I also excluded the words invading, raiding and occupying that were imbedded in source materials because that little piece of Americana would imply the War of Northern Aggression was somehow begun by Northern Armies crossing the Potomac out of boredom or spite to take away states rights (but never for reasons that had anything to do with slavery) - Rather than an armed conflict begun when a federal garrison stationed by a duly elected government was bombarded at Fort Sumter by Confederate forces. Just sayin’
Frequently, historical materials offhandedly proclaim Vigna unguiculata was brought to the colonial US by slaves, without ever explaining how people who physically had nothing carried, planted and harvested seeds under a fearful, watchful and suspicious eye. A better way of stating the emergence of the plant on a new continent is to say the legume was brought to the colonial US with the slave trade. Originally harvested in Africa, which still produces about 90% of the world’s crop, trade and migration moved black-eyed peas north, east and west over time. Ancient Greeks (and people on the sub-content) were growing and consuming the plant centuries before the new world was discovered by Europeans.
Eating Hoppin’ John, like many of our food traditions, is distinctly Southern in origin. Largely thought of as soul food, black-eyed peas were consumed by both blacks and whites. Black-eyed peas were grown at Monticello and according to obsessively detailed records were served at Jefferson’s table. A popular version of the story actually credits Jefferson himself as the inventor of Hoppin’ John. After having tasted the bean and pork favorite, cassoulet during his time spent as an Ambassador in France, Jefferson recreated the dish using American food. The tale seems to be a bit of whitewashing – for what slaves, who did most of the plantation cooking, lacked in material possessions they still had memories and customs to draw on - giving a humble dish regal heritage. Jefferson himself proves that race is far more complicated than it first appears to be.
Besides anyone from either South or North state will tell you a Virginian could have never invented the regional dish of the Carolinas. Whatever the origin of Hoppin’ John, there does seem to be a great deal of celebration associated with eating something by choice rather than necessity.
Happy 2009









